Advanced search
Visit
8282
Last Updated: 2006/08/30
Summary of question
What is the ruling on forming lines in congregational, when a third person joins in?
question
What is the ruling if two people are making salat (with the Imam in front and the second person beside him), and a third person wants to join in? I recently went to a mosque where I was praying alone with the Imam, and a third person grabbed my arm and pulled me back in order to form a line behind the Imam.
Concise answer

In reference to the incident which you experienced, we must first look at the principals of forming lines in congregational prayer from a fiqhi point of view:

  1. The person following in prayer should not be ahead of the person leading the prayer (the Imam).[1]

  2. It is Mustahab (merited) that if there is one person following the prayer and he is male, that he stand on the right side of the Imam[2] and based on obligatory precaution he should stand just slightly further behind the Imam, and if there are several persons following the prayer then they should form a line behind the Imam.[3]

So apparently in this case, both of the individuals following the prayer were trying to do their Islamic duties. However in reply to the question as to whether or not the action of the Second Ma'moom (person following the prayer) which caused the movement of the first Ma'moom, is grounds for the invalidation of the first Ma'moom's prayer; the following must be said:

Scholars say: Any action which disrupts the structure of prayer will invalidate the prayer, such as; clapping, jumping up and down, etc.[4]

The Late Sayyid Muhammad Kazem Tabataba'ee Yazdi states[5]:

There is no harm in walking two, three or more steps during salat in such a way that the direction of the qibla is correctly maintained[6], for the reason that this amount is not regarded as 'excess movement’. However, the criterion is not '‘excess’' rather it is, "the disrupting of prayer structure", and with this amount or even possibly more the structure of prayer is not disrupted. So taking that into consideration, there are also hadith which express the permissibility of this issue.[7]

So in congregational prayer there is nothing wrong with slight movement in order to make the line neat or to make room for someone else to pray.

Grand Ayatollah Makarem Shirazi's response to this question:

There is nothing wrong with this act in itself, so long as when the Ma’moom moves slightly backwards the Imam is not in the state of reciting any dhikr.



[1] Some scholars have prohibited standing parallel. - Catechism of Legal Authorities, Vol.1, Pg.781 & 782 Ques.1432

[2] Some scholars have elaborated on this merited act in their catechism - Catechism of Legal Authorities, Vol.1

[3]Catechism of Legal Authorities- Section: Alwasilah Ila Nilul Fazilah, Pg.107; Jameh Abbasi and it’s Completion (Mahshi), Vol.1, Pg.96

[4]Catechism of Legal Authorities, Vol.1, Pg.628 Ques.1151

[5]Sayyid Muhammad Kazem Tabataba'ee Yazdi, Questions and Answers, Pg.47 (Jame’ul Fiqh Software)

[6]Standing in face of the qibla

[7]Wasa’il Ul-Shia, Vol.4, Pg.1279, Narration 1 & Vol.5, Pg.443, Section 43, Congregated Prayer; Man La Yahzer, Vol.1, Pg.277, Narration 851 & Vol.1 Pg.494, Narration 1421; Al-Kafi, Vol.3, Pg.272, 316 & 385; Tahzibul Ahkam, vol.3, Pg.275, Narration 119

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Random questions

  • Can a gold seller, sell jewelries to those women that he/she knows they use it in front of Non-Mahram?
    6638 خرید و فروش 2013/10/26
    What has caused selling to be Haram and corrupted is not upon knowing that woman wear these gold and jewelries in the way of Haram, unless he/she intended the selling that those jewelries should be used in the way of Haram, only. However, it would be permissible ...
  • How do plants and inanimate objects glorify God, the Exalted?
    19537 Traditional 2012/10/15
    Man's knowledge about creatures of the world is truly restricted and unmentionable. How Dif y restricted and unmentionable. nanimate objects testiory? different creatures glorify God is still unknown to humans. In several Quranic verses and in traditions it has been stated that all parts ...
  • What is the ruling on having a relation with a non-mahram girl before marriage?
    24381 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/10/02
    Any form of relationship before marriage, let it be speaking intimately, touching and caressing etc. is haram. If one speaks with a girl with the intention of seeking pleasure or if he fears that he might fall into a sin with her, it is not permissible for ...
  • What is our duty towards street beggars?
    21362 Practical 2012/09/03
    It is good to help every beggar even if he is not poor but it is necessary to focus our attention on priorities keeping in view the fact that our financial resources are limited. In the present time in which there are certain institutions tasked to identify ...
  • What causes jello to become haram or halal?
    18739 Laws and Jurisprudence 2007/02/14
    There exists different types of jello; some are deemed halal, others haram. The criterion which classifies jello as being either halal or haram to consume, is that of its initial ingredients. Assuming the latter are all ‘herbal’, all jello types – domestic/foreign – are halal and permissible to consume. However, ...
  • Does verse 159 of Surah al-An\'am make reference to disunity and discord in the religion of Islam or to all divine religions?
    9985 Exegesis 2015/06/18
    The Holy Quran says in verses 159 of Chapter al-An'am: «إِنَّ الَّذِينَ فَرَّقُوا دِينَهُمْ وَ كانُوا شِيَعاً لَسْتَ مِنْهُمْ فِي شَيْ‏ءٍ إِنَّما أَمْرُهُمْ إِلَى اللَّهِ ثُمَّ يُنَبِّئُهُمْ بِما كانُوا يَفْعَلُونَ‏» "Surely they who divided their religion into parts and became sects, you ...
  • Is it Haram to steal something back from someone who has already stolen it from you?
    12642 Laws and Jurisprudence 2013/08/12
    There is no problem if you believe the object is the one that has been stolen from you and you are not able to take it back legally and peacefully, but it should be done with no mischief. Appendix: The grand jurisprudent’s verdict in this regard is ...
  • How long has the belief in Wilayatul Faqih existed?
    6587 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/08/01
    The concept of Wilayatul Faqih, taken to mean the leadership of a society under an individual who has reached the rank of ‘Ijtihad’ (Jurisprudence) in Fiqh, is according to some, a new concept in terms of Islamic thought and first originated ...
  • Is it lawful to get a marital judgment from a non-Muslim government?
    6350 Fiqh 2007/01/07
    Referring to judicial arbitrators in non-Muslim and oppressive governments, and requesting their help is not permissible, save in cases where attaining one's right is dependent upon it, and there is no other way. And it is obvious that taking ...
  • What is the limit of freedom in Islam and Shi’ism?
    7747 Traditional 2010/10/13
    Depending on the contexts, freedom has different meanings and the limits of freedom are different with the difference of its meanings:1- Freedom in the sense of existential independence, something exclusive to an absolute being and to God, the Exalted who ...

Popular